CAID
Christian
                  Aboriginal
                                      Infrastructure
                                                        Developments

 

Featured

Meaningful Consultation in Canada: The Alternative to Forced Aboriginal Assimilation

United Nations’ Recommendations on the Duty to Consult

Senate Standing Committee on Aboriginal Peoples Report on Canada’s North

Arctic Perishable Food Mail Program Review and Recommendations

Amnesty International - Canada: Submission to the UN Universal Periodic Review

Indigenous Children's Health Report: Health Assessment in Action

 

Last Updated September 15, 2015

Foundation for a Sustainable Northern Future:

Report of the Joint Review Panel for the Mackenzie Gas Project (2009)

 

Volume 2

Full Document

 

CHAPTER 11 — Conservation Management and Protected Areas

11.1 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 331

11.2 APPROACHES AND METHODS............................................................................................ 332

11.2.1 PROPONENTS’ APPROACH.................................................................................... 332

11.2.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................ 333

11.2.3 PANEL VIEWS.................................................................................................... 334

11.3 IMPACTS ON PROTECTED AREAS AND AREAS OF HIGH CONSERVATION VALUE............................ 335

11.3.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 335

11.3.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 338

11.3.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 338

11.4 IMPACTS ON LAND USE PLANS AND OCEAN MANAGEMENT...................................................... 341

11.4.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 341

11.4.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 342

11.4.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 342

11.5 IMPACT ASSESSMENT: INUVIALUIT SETTLEMENT REGION....................................................... 345

11.5.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 345

11.5.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 346

11.5.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 348

11.6 IMPACT ASSESSMENT: GWICH’IN SETTLEMENT AREA............................................................ 349

11.6.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 349

11.6.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 349

11.6.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 350

11.7 IMPACT ASSESSMENT: SAHTU SETTLEMENT AREA................................................................ 350

11.7.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 350

11.7.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 350

11.7.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 351

11.8 IMPACT ASSESSMENT: DELCHO REGION............................................................................. 352

11.8.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 352

11.8.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 352

11.8.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 352

11.9 IMPACT ASSESSMENT: NORTHWEST ALBERTA...................................................................... 353

11.9.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 353

11.9.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 353

11.9.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 353

11.10 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS............................................................................. 353

11.10.1 PROTECTED AREAS........................................................................................... 356

11.10.2 REGIONAL LAND USE PLANS AND COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLANS......................... 358

 

CHAPTER 12 — Harvesting

12.1 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 365

12.2 IMPACTS ON HARVESTER ACCESS..................................................................................... 366

12.2.1 Proponents’ Views.............................................................................................. 366

12.2.2 Participants ’ Views............................................................................................ 367

12.2.3 Panel Views...................................................................................................... 367

12.3 HARVESTER COMPENSATION (NORTHWEST TERRITORIES)...................................................... 368

12.3.1 Existing Conditions............................................................................................. 368

12.3.2 Proponents’ Views.............................................................................................. 368

12.3.3 Participants ’ Views and Recommendations ............................................................. 371

12.3.4 Panel Views and Recommendations ....................................................................... 373

12.4 HARVESTER COMPENSATION (ALBERTA)...............................................................................374

12.4.1 Existing Conditions............................................................................................. 374

12.4.2 Proponents’ and NOVA Gas Transmission ltd .’s Views................................................ 375

12.4.3 Participants ’ Views............................................................................................ 375

12.4.4 Panel Views and Recommendations ....................................................................... 375

12.5 WORST-CASE SCENARIOS IN THE INUVIALUIT SETTLEMENT REGION: MITIGATION

AND POTENTIAL LIABILITY OF THE PROPONENTS............................................................... 376

12.5.1 Proponents’ Mitigations ...................................................................................... 376

12.5.2 Estimate of Potential Liability................................................................................ 377

12.5.3 Panel Views and Recommendation .........................................................................377

 

CHAPTER 13 — Land Use and Heritage Resources

13.1 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 381

13.2 LAND OWNERSHIP AND ACCESS......................................................................................... 381

13.2.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 381

13.2.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 383

13.2.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS......................................................................................... 385

13.2.4 PANEL VIEWS..................................................................................................... 386

13.3 GRANULAR RESOURCES..................................................................................................... 386

13.3.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 386

13.3.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 386

13.3.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................... 388

13.3.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................... 389

13.4 TIMBER RESOURCES......................................................................................................... 391

13.4.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS......................................................................................... 391

13.4.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 392

13.4.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................... 393

13.4.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................... 394

13.5 TOURISM AND OUTDOOR RECREATION................................................................................. 395

13.5.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 395

13.5.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 395

13.5.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 396

13.5.4 PANEL VIEWS.................................................................................................... 397

13.6 HERITAGE AND HISTORICAL RESOURCES.............................................................................. 397

13.6.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 397

13.6.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 398

13.6.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 399

13.6.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................. 400

CHAPTER 14 — Physical Infrastructure and Housing

14.1 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 405

14.2 TRANSPORTATION.......................................................................................................... 406

14.2.1 RAIL TRANSPORTATION....................................................................................... 406

14.2.2 ROAD TRANSPORTATION...................................................................................... 409

14.2.3 BARGE TRANSPORTATION..................................................................................... 415

14.2.4 AIR TRANSPORTATION......................................................................................... 420

14.3 LOCAL INFRASTRUCTURE.................................................................................................. 423

14.3.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 423

14.3.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 424

14.3.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................... 425

14.3.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................... 427

14.4 GAS SUPPLY TO COMMUNITIES AND OTHER SMALL-MARKET CONSUMERS.................................. 427

14.4.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 427

14.4.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 428

14.4.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................... 428

14.4.4 PANEL VIEWS.................................................................................................... 429

14.5 HOUSING...................................................................................................................... 429

14.5.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 430

14.5.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 431

14.5.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 433

14.5.4 PANEL VIEWS.................................................................................................... 435

 

CHAPTER 15 — Economic Impacts

15.1 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 439

15.2 METHODS AND APPROACH................................................................................................ 439

15.2.1 SOURCES AND METHODS..................................................................................... 439

15.2.2 PANEL APPROACH............................................................................................... 441

15.3 PROJECT EXPENDITURES AND GDP IMPACTS........................................................................ 442

15.3.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 442

15.3.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................ 445

15.3.3 PANEL VIEWS.................................................................................................... 445

15.4 PROCUREMENT AND BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES.................................................................... 447

15.4.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 447

15.4.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 450

15.4.3 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................. 452

15.5 LABOUR FORCE DEVELOPMENT........................................................................................... 453

15.5.1 INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................. 453

15.5.2 EXISTING CONDITIONS........................................................................................ 454

15.5.3 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 458

15.5.4 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 460

15.5.5 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................. 461

15.6 EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR INCOME................................................................................... 463

15.6.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 463

15.6.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 469

15.6.3 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................. 471

15.7 REVENUES TO GOVERNMENTS........................................................................................... 473

15.7.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 473

15.7.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...................................................... 475

15.7.3 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................. 477

15.8 OVERALL PANEL FINDINGS ON ECONOMIC IMPACTS............................................................... 480

15.8.1 CONSTRUCTION PHASE........................................................................................ 480

15.8.2 OPERATIONS PHASE............................................................................................ 481

15.8.3 PROJECT LEGACY................................................................................................ 482

15.8.4 EXPANSION CAPACITY SCENARIO........................................................................... 484

 

CHAPTER 16 — Social and Cultural Impacts

16.1 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 487

16.2 APPROACH AND METHODS................................................................................................ 488

16.2.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 488

16.2.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS......................................................................................... 489

16.2.3 PANEL VIEWS..................................................................................................... 490

16.3 EXISTING CONDITIONS..................................................................................................... 491

16.3.1 HEALTH, SOCIAL WELL-BEING AND COMMUNITY CONDITIONS...................................... 491

16.3.2 HEALTH CARE, SOCIAL SERVICE AND PROTECTION FACILITIES AND SERVICES................ 493

16.4 DIRECT PROJECT IMPACTS................................................................................................ 495

16.4.1 SOUTHERN WORKERS AND POTENTIAL INTERACTIONS WITH COMMUNITIES

IN THE PROJECT REVIEW AREA.............................................................................. 495

16.4.2 PROJECT-INDUCED MIGRATION TO REGIONAL CENTRES.............................................. 498

16.4.3 HEALTH IMPACTS............................................................................................... 499

16.5 IMPACTS ON COMMUNITIES AND GOVERNMENT SERVICES........................................................501

16.5.1 ALCOHOL, DRUGS AND GAMBLING........................................................................... 502

16.5.2 WELL-BEING CONDITIONS AND SOCIAL SERVICE DELIVERY.......................................... 507

16.5.3 POLICING AND SAFETY......................................................................................... 513

16.5.4 CHILD CARE........................................................................................................ 517

16.5.5 HOMELESSNESS.................................................................................................. 518

16.5.6 WOMEN’S SHELTERS............................................................................................ 519

16.5.7 ELDER CARE........................................................................................................ 521

16.5.8 SUICIDE............................................................................................................ 522

16.5.9 TRADITIONAL LANGUAGE AND CULTURE.................................................................... 523

16.6 SHARED RESPONSIBILITY MODEL........................................................................................ 529

16.6.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 529

16.6.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS......................................................................................... 530

16.6.3 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATION..................................................................... 531

16.7 SOCIO-ECONOMIC MANAGEMENT SYSTEM............................................................................ 532

16.7.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 532

16.7.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS......................................................................................... 533

16.7.3 PANEL VIEWS..................................................................................................... 533

16.8 SOCIO-ECONOMIC AGREEMENT.......................................................................................... 534

16.8.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................... 534

16.8.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS....................................................... 534

16.8.3 PANEL VIEWS..................................................................................................... 535

16.9 MACKENZIE GAS PROJECT IMPACTS FUND............................................................................ 535

16.9.1 PURPOSE, OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE......................................................................... 535

16.9.2 KEY FEATURES AND PRINCIPLES............................................................................. 536

16.9.3 STRUCTURES AND INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK........................................................ 536

16.9.4 IMPLEMENTATION................................................................................................ 537

16.9.5 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 537

16.9.6 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................... 540

16.10 OVERALL VIEWS............................................................................................................. 541

16.10.1 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS.......................................................................................... 541

16.10.2 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS........................................................................................ 541

16.10.3 PANEL VIEWS.................................................................................................... 542

 

CHAPTER 17 — Decommissioning and Abandonment

17.1 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 545

17.2 PROPONENTS’ VIEWS....................................................................................................... 545

17.3 PARTICIPANTS’ VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................... 546

17.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS............................................................................... 546

CHAPTER 18 — Monitoring, Follow-up and Management Plans

18.1 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 551

18.1.1 PURPOSE AND IMPORTANCE OF MONITORING AND FOLLOW-UP..................................... 551

18.1.2 TYPES OF MONITORING........................................................................................ 552

18.2 PROJECT MONITORING AND FOLLOW -UP.............................................................................. 553

18.2.1 BIOPHYSICAL MONITORING.................................................................................... 553

18.2.2 SOCIO-ECONOMIC MONITORING............................................................................. 558

18.2.3 GOVERNMENT AND OTHER INSTITUTIONAL ROLES...................................................... 562

18.2.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................... 565

18.3 CUMULATIVE IMPACTS MONITORING AND MANAGEMENT.......................................................... 571

18.3.1 EXISTING CONDITIONS......................................................................................... 571

18.3.2 CUMULATIVE IMPACTS MANAGEMENT...................................................................... 572

18.3.3 CUMULATIVE IMPACTS OF FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS.................................................... 574

18.3.4 PANEL VIEWS AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................... 576

18.3.5 FOLLOW-UP PROGRAM FOR CUMULATIVE IMPACTS MANAGEMENT AND MONITORING......... 578

 

CHAPTER 19 — Sustainability and Net Contribution

19.1 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 585

19.2 APPROACH..................................................................................................................... 586

19.3 THE CORE QUESTION....................................................................................................... 586

19.4 THE SCOPE OF DEVELOPMENTS TO BE ASSESSED................................................................. 586

19.5 KEY SUSTAINABILITY ISSUES............................................................................................ 589

19.6 SUMMARY OF PANEL ANALYSIS OF THE FIVE KEY SUSTAINABILITY ISSUES CATEGORIES...............590

19.6.1 Cumulative Impacts on the Biophysical Environment.................................................. 591

19.6.2 Cumulative Impacts on the Human Environment........................................................ 595

19.6.3 Equity Impacts .................................................................................................. 599

19.6.4 Legacy and Bridging Impacts ................................................................................ 602

19.6.5 Cumulative Impacts Management and Preparedness .................................................. 604

19.6.6 Interaction of Project Impacts .............................................................................. 606

19.7 EVALUATION OF THE PROJECT’S CONTRIBUTION TO SUSTAINABILITY....................................... 608

19.7.1 The Project as Filed with a Throughput of 0.83 Bcf/d................................................ 608

19.7.2 The Project as Filed with Expanded Throughput in the Range

of 0.83 to 1.2 Bcf/d..................................................................................................... 609

19.7.3 The Project as Filed Expanded in the Range from 1.2 Bcf/d

to its Design Capacity of 1.8 Bcf/d................................................................................. 610

19.7.4 The Project as Filed and Other Future Scenarios...................................................... 611

19.7.5 The Null Alternative ........................................................................................... 612

19.8 TRADE-OFFS................................................................................................................. 612

19.9 CONCERNS REGARDING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PANEL’S RECOMMENDATIONS

BY GOVERNMENT......................................................................................................... 612

19.10 CONCLUSIONS.............................................................................................................. 614

 

APPENDICES

Appendix 1: Agreement Establishing the Joint Review Panel for the Mackenzie Gas Project.................. 620

Appendix 2: Biographies of Joint Review Panel Members ............................................................... 630

Appendix 3: Direction on Procedures......................................................................................... 632

Appendix 4: List of Parties ..................................................................................................... 640

Appendix 5: List of Public Informati on Sessions.......................................................................... 641

Appendix 6: List of Hearings, Dates and Locati ons...................................................................... 642

Appendix 7: Determinati on on sufficiency.................................................................................. 645

Appendix 8: Criteria for Confidentiality Orders for Traditional Knowledge Study Reports....................... 647

Appendix 9: Selected Rulings on Motions................................................................................... 649

Appendix 10: Summary Reports of Community Hearings................................................................ 650

Aklavik Community Hearing, June 19, 2007....................................................................... 650

Colville Lake Community Hearing, April 10, 2006................................................................ 651

Déline Community Hearing, April 3, 2006.......................................................................... 651

Fort Good Hope Community Hearing No. 1, April 11, 2006.................................................... 652

Fort Good Hope Community Hearing No. 2, April 12, 2006.................................................... 653

Fort Liard Community Hearing, May 12, 2006.................................................................... 654

Fort McPherson Community Hearing, February 17, 2006...................................................... 655

Fort Providence Community Hearing No. 1, June 14, 2006.................................................... 655

Fort Providence Community Hearing No. 2, June 15, 2006.................................................... 656

Fort Simpson Community Hearing No. 1, May 8, 2006.......................................................... 657

Fort Simpson Community Hearing No. 2, May 9, 2006.......................................................... 657

Hay River Community Hearing, June 9, 2006...................................................................... 658

Hay River Reserve Community Hearing, June 8, 2006........................................................... 658

High Level Community Hearing No. 1, July 5, 2006............................................................... 659

High Level Community Hearing No. 2, July 6, 2006............................................................... 660

Inuvik Community Hearing No. 1, January 8, 2007............................................................... 660

Inuvik Community Hearing No. 2, January 9, 2007............................................................... 661

Jean Marie River Community Hearing, May 15, 2006............................................................ 661

Kakisa Community Hearing, June 13, 2006......................................................................... 662

Norman Wells Community Hearing, April 6, 2006.................................................................. 663

Paulatuk Community Hearing, September 7, 2006................................................................ 663

Sachs Harbour Community Hearing, September 9, 2006........................................................ 664

Trout Lake Community Hearing, May 16, 2006.................................................................... 665

Tsiigehtchic Community Hearing, February 20, 2006............................................................ 666

Tuktoyaktuk Community Hearing No. 1, September 11, 2006................................................. 666

Tuktoyaktuk Community Hearing No. 2, September 15, 2006................................................. 667

Tuktoyaktuk Community Hearing No. 3, June 20, 2007......................................................... 668

Tulita Community Hearing No. 1, April 4, 2006.................................................................... 668

Tulita Community Hearing No. 2, April 5, 2006.................................................................... 669

Ulukhaktok Community Hearing, September 8, 2006............................................................. 669

Wrigley Community Hearing, May 11, 2006........................................................................ 670

Appendix 11: Glossary............................................................................................................ 672